Is there a hidden “Bible code”?

Settled(green)Evidence from:Science

Short answer

No. Researchers found similar “codes” in other long books like Moby Dick; it’s a statistical artifact.

What Scripture says

Scripture claims to be God’s word, with a plain message meant to be understood: “All Scripture is breathed out by God and profitable for teaching” (2 Timothy 3:16, ESV). Its prophecies are given openly in the text, not hidden in letter patterns. God condemns trying to discover the future through divination (Deuteronomy 18:10–12).

What the evidence says

Science

What the “Bible code” claims

The Bible code claims that hidden messages are encoded in the Hebrew text of the Torah, found by equidistant letter sequences (ELS): starting at a letter and skipping a fixed number of letters (say, every 50th) to spell out words. Proponents arrange the text in a grid and look for related words crossing nearby.

The history

  • In 1994, Israeli researchers Doron Witztum, Eliyahu Rips and Yoav Rosenberg published a paper in the journal Statistical Science claiming the names of famous rabbis appeared in Genesis close to their dates of birth or death, more often than chance would predict. The journal’s editor presented it as a “challenging puzzle”.
  • In 1997, journalist Michael Drosnin’s bestseller The Bible Code claimed the code predicted the assassination of Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin, and that it predicted a world war, or an atomic attack, in the year 2000 or 2006.

How it was refuted

Drosnin challenged critics: “When my critics find a message about the assassination of a prime minister encrypted in Moby Dick, I’ll believe them.”

The Australian mathematician Brendan McKay took up the challenge. Using the same method on Moby Dick, he found “predictions” of the assassinations of Indira Gandhi, Martin Luther King, John F. Kennedy and Rabin, and of Princess Diana’s death.

In 1999, McKay and three Israeli mathematicians and statisticians published a detailed refutation in the same journal, Statistical Science. They showed that the original study’s results depended on choices made in selecting names and dates. With so many possible spellings and ways to search, researchers could, without intending to, tune the experiment until it worked. When they made similar choices, they found equally impressive results in a Hebrew translation of War and Peace.

Text Search “Hits” found
Genesis (Witztum et al.) Rabbis’ names and dates Claimed significant
War and Peace (McKay et al.) Same rabbis, adjusted choices Equally significant
Moby Dick (McKay) Famous assassinations Many

Why it works on any long book

In any long text, the number of possible letter sequences is enormous. With freedom to choose skip distances, starting points, spellings and which words count as “related”, meaningful-looking patterns will appear by chance, just as people see faces in clouds.

Drosnin’s predictions also failed: there was no world war or atomic attack in 2000 or 2006.

A textual problem

The Bible code also assumes that the Hebrew text is letter-for-letter identical to the original. But manuscripts differ slightly in spelling (see 4.1, 4.2). A single added or missing letter would destroy any code with long skips, though it wouldn’t affect the meaning of the text.

Where they meet

There is no hidden Bible code. Researchers found similar “codes” in other long books like Moby Dick; it’s a statistical artefact.

What’s still open

Nothing of substance.

Bottom line

No. Researchers found similar “codes” in other long books like Moby Dick; it’s a statistical artefact. This is rated Settled.

Sources

  1. Doron Witztum, Eliyahu Rips and Yoav Rosenberg, Equidistant Letter Sequences in the Book of Genesis (1994). Published in Statistical Science; the original claim.
  2. Brendan McKay, Dror Bar-Natan, Maya Bar-Hillel and Gil Kalai, Solving the Bible Code Puzzle (1999). Published in Statistical Science; the refutation.
  3. Michael Drosnin, The Bible Code (1997)
  4. Jeffrey Satinover, Cracking the Bible Code (1997). A sympathetic account.

Bible quotations: ESV.

Learn more

Outside resources for going deeper. Some come from viewpoints this site disagrees with; each is marked.

Articles